Coterie means a gathering of people with common tastes. Pizza is a food to share…
In his spare time, Chris makes pizzas in his backyard oven for anyone who comes over. Harvey is a next door neighbor who loves pizza. This is how their families began to hang out – over pizza, which developed into a friendship. Eventually, a vision was formed out of this camaraderie of wanting to bring this experience to life in a local community.
Coterie Pizza utilizes a master crafted Italian stone oven and pizzas that try to match. We try to be unique and keep the classics safe that everyone can enjoy or explore. Add a self-pour beer wall, ample seating, community events and you will see our desire to grow in Garrett, IN. Try our pizza, join our Coterie!
We are futuristically looking to add outdoor seating, as well as more menu items. Check back often! You won’t be disappointed!
These pizzas are awesome. The hot honey pepperoni with ricotta was probably my favorite, but the artichoke and sun dried tomato was a very close second. You can really taste the quality of ingredients and these guys know what they’re doing.
Best of the best! Came in with my fiance and we had the cheesy bread and the brisket burnt ends pizza. Seriously so delicious! Staff were so very kind and helpful. If you’re looking for a local place with great food and service, this is the place! We will be back regularly!
Such a warm, friendly, and cozy place to dine in. The food is amazing and the service is great!
Contact us today to enjoy our finest, homemade Italian cuisines.