Loading today's hours...
Where We Started
Chris Zaugg was making pizzas in his backyard oven for anyone who came over. His next door neighbor Harvey loved pizza, the two families became friends, and that's how we ended up opening in Garrett.
The Stone Oven
Every pizza goes through our master crafted Italian stone oven. Try the Margherita. The crust comes out firm with a slight chew.
Beer Cheese and Bread
Start with the beer cheese. Order it alongside a pizza and you'll likely have leftovers to take home.
Build Your Own
Start with cheese and add what you like. Green peppers, onions and mushrooms are on the list, and we have whole Kalamata olives too.
Pour Your Own Beer
Seat yourself, and our team will walk you through the beer wall. You get a bracelet, scan it at the tap and pay by the ounce. Beer and wine are both on tap.
Coterie Pizza Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are your most popular dishes?
Coterie Pizza is known for pizza with both classic and spicy toppings, plus baked bread starters. Our most popular dishes include:
- Hot Honey Pizza: Ricotta and pepperoni with a hot honey drizzle and crushed red pepper flakes.
- Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza: A pizza with mild Italian sausage, spicy Italian sausage and pepperoni.
- Cajun Pizza: Roasted chicken, spicy sausage, green peppers and banana peppers are topped with a cajun heat drizzle.
- Margherita Pizza: Fresh mozzarella and basil go on this pizza, finished with an olive oil drizzle.
- Cheese Bread: Garlic butter and cheese top freshly baked bread, served with marinara.
- Beer Cheese Dip: A creamy beer cheese dip accompanied by freshly baked bread.
Check out our full menu.
What are you known for?
We’re known for pizzas with hot honey, brisket, and gluten-free options, alongside penne pasta, Italian sandwiches, and Greek-style salads.
- Italian Food: Italian-inspired dishes span Margherita and mushroom pizzas, gluten-free options, penne pasta, sandwiches, and Caprese salad. Examples include Margherita, Gluten Free Mushroom Medley, Classic Penne, Italian Sandwich, and Caprese Salad.
- Pizza: Pizzas range from cheese and pepperoni to hot honey, brisket, and spinach artichoke, with multiple sizes and gluten-free options. Examples include Cheese Pizza, 12" Pep, 16" Hot Honey, Brisket, 16" Spinach Artichoke, and Gluten Free Chicken Bruschetta.
- Salads: Salads include Caesar, Greek, Italian chopped, and Caprese styles, with half and full portions for house and Greek options. Examples include Coterie Caesar, Greek Goddess, Italian Chop Salad, Caprese Salad, Half House, and Full House.
- Sandwiches: Sandwich options cover vegetables, sausage, ham and cheese, and an Italian-style offering. Examples include Veggie Sandwich, Sausage Sandwich, Italian Sandwich, and Ham and Cheese Sandwich.
- Pasta: Penne comes in classic and rustic styles, alongside a beer cheese and bacon option. Examples include Classic Penne, Rustic Penne, and Beer Cheese and Bacon.
Do you offer catering?
Yes! Coterie Pizza offers catering for parties, office lunches, family gatherings, and other events.
Visit our catering page for more information.
What payment methods do you accept?
When you order online, we accept credit cards (Mastercard, Visa, American Express, Discover), Apple Pay, and Google Pay.
Services & amenities
Is your restaurant wheelchair accessible? Yes, our restaurant is wheelchair accessible.
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Albion, Butler Center, Cedar, Garrett, Saint Johns, Altona, Port Mitchell, New Era, Bakertown, Swan, Laotto, Brimfield, Auburn, Burr Oak, Wawaka, Egans Point, Avilla, Wolflake, Lisbon, and Noble County.
